The Best Mattress Pads

Utopia Bedding Quilted Fitted Mattress

Quality Shut-Eye

This silky smooth quilted mattress pad slides over your mattress like a billowy fitted sheet.

Best Overall

Find on Amazon

When you think of mattress pads, you might initially think of memory foam, but there is a whole world of other types of pads out there. This one from Utopia Bedding is a delicately soft diamond-stitch quilted mattress pad. It goes over your bed just like a fitted sheet but provides extra support on top via the comfortable fiberfill pad filling. This mattress pad separates itself from the pack with its relatively thin structure. Many of these products are far bulkier, but Utopia Bedding goes for a subtler, understated design. Not to mention, this pad is also eminently affordable, so for all sleepers looking to save, scoop this pad up right away.

Pros:

• Goes on as easy as a fitted sheet
• Ideal for those looking for less bulk
• Affordable

Cons:

• Doesn’t offer quite as much support as other mattress pads on the market

Easeland Quilted Fitted Mattress Pad

Hit the Hay

This quilted feather mattress pad promises many well-rested nights with its breathable fabric and soft down-alternative filling.

Best Pillow Top

Find on Amazon

While this quilted mattress pad from Easeland doesn’t use real down filling, their down-alternative is just as comfortable. The 100% cotton sheet fits over any mattress under 21” deep, so it’s compatible with most sizes. Easeland offers seven different size options to accommodate all types of beds. The prices go up progressively, but even the largest size is still affordable. This mattress pad also offers some relief to night-sweaters with its breathable, cooling design.

Pros:

• Comfortable down-alternative filling
• Compatible with any bed under 21”
• Breathable, cooling sheet design
• Available in all bed sizes

Cons:

• Quilted design doesn’t offer much support

Coonp Extra Thick Mattress Topper

Cloud Nine

This cloud-like mattress pad is the perfect pick for sleepers who love all things soft.

Softest

Find on Amazon

As the old saying goes, “go big or go home.” This ultra-soft mattress pad from Coonp definitely goes big. If you’ve always dreamt of sleeping on a cloud, we imagine that this is the closest you’ll be able to get to it. Coonp stuffed this mattress pad to the brim with ultra-soft down-alternative filling to give you a billowy sleep sanctuary to fall into at night. The microfiber top surface feels smooth as velvet and breathable enough to keep you cool during warm nights. Not to mention, this pad is machine-washable, which means no more stressing over trips to the dry cleaners. We highly recommend it to anyone craving a cloud-like sleeping experience.

Pros:

• Super billowy and comfy
• Breathable microfiber sheet
• Fits on all mattresses up to 21”

Cons:

• Due to its lack of support, it’s best used as a supplement to a sturdy mattress

Classic Brands 3-Inch Memory Foam Mattress Topper

The Right Side of the Bed

This elegantly comfy foam mattress pad is a worthwhile buy for any memory foam fanatic.

Best Memory Foam

Find on Amazon

If you love the feeling of sinking into a memory foam mattress, but can’t afford their hefty price tags, this memory foam mattress pad from Classic Brands is right up your alley. You can give any old mattress a high-quality memory foam makeover in seconds with this mattress pad. The pad molds to your form and relieves stress and pressure in your body from your daily routine. And for our fellow clean freaks out there, memory foam mattress pads such as this one are naturally antimicrobial and resistant to mold, bacteria, and allergens. For anyone looking for a small-budget alternative to pricy memory foam mattresses, look no further than this pad from Classic Brands.

Pros:

• Offers support and relieves pressure
• Affordable alternative to memory foam mattresses
• Naturally antimicrobial

Cons:

• Memory foam tends to get warmer than some other mattress pad materials

Sure2Sleep Gel Swirl Memory Foam

Let Yourself Drift Off

This innovative gel-swirl memory foam mattress pad is an ideal sleep solution for those with chronic back pain.

Most Support

Find on Amazon

Memory foam mattresses are notorious for keeping the bed too warm, but this breathable mattress pad from Sure2Sleep is here to break away from the stereotype. With Sure2Sleep’s innovative gel-swirl infused memory foam, this mattress pad stays cool and comfortable all night long. As the foam contours to your body, hard-working muscle groups are finally given some much-needed R&R. This mattress pad is a little pricey, but we think it’s more than worth it for those looking for a comfortable and supported night’s sleep.

Pros:

• Ideal for those dealing with chronic back pain
• Cooling gel-swirl infused design
• Memory foam construction supports you as you sleep

Cons:

• Might be a bit stiff for some sleepers

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I buy a mattress pad in place of a mattress?

Mattress pads are meant to be used as supplementary sleep products. They aren’t thick or sturdy enough to comfortably support your body when sleeping. To experience the full value of a mattress pad, you have to place it on top of a mattress.

What are the most common materials for mattress pads?

The most popular mattress pad material is probably foam, but there are plenty of other choices to consider. Companies also use latex, wool, feather, and polyester blends for mattress pads. Be sure to research the different types and choose the one that best suits your sleep habits.