The Best Brown Mascara

Cover Girl Lash Blast Volume Mascara

Brown blast

This Covergirl Lash Blast formula will make every lash stand out and its medium-brown color is a stunning shade.

Best Overall

Find on Amazon

If you haven’t tried Cover Girl’s Lash Blast mascara yet, now is the time. This incredible formula is designed to separate every single lash with its thin but effective color. Its innovative wand is designed specifically to never clump and it’s easy to use on both top and bottom lashes, too.

This mascara comes in multiple shades, one of which is a beautiful medium-brown. It boasts the ability to make your lashes up to ten times more voluminous than their bare size, and it can be layered for a more dramatic look as well. It comes in both waterproof and washable versions for your convenience.

Pros:

• This mascara has a fairly affordable price point
• It’s made by Cover Girl, a brand that’s been creating quality cosmetic products for over 50 years
• The wand is double-sided to allow for purposeful separating and defining

Cons:

• This only comes in a few shades, though the offered options work well for most makeup looks

Vivienne Sabo Cruelty-Free French Mascara

Kind and classy

Stay away from animal testing with this cruelty-free French mascara and its beautiful brown hue.

Best Cruelty Free

Find on Amazon

This mascara from Vivienne Sabo is all about quality and cruelty-free creation. It’s never tested on animals, so you can beautify your lashes guilt-free every day. It’s also designed in France with a special single-coat formula, so you can quickly and easily transform your makeup routine.

Along with only needing a single coat, this brown mascara goes on smooth. It’s made to be completely clump-free and lightweight, providing a cohesive look that still leaves your lashes feeling as soft and natural as possible.

Pros:

• The small wand is designed to easily reach every lash 
• The formula is waterproof and easy to take off with makeup remover
• Primer is available to purchase if you’re looking for a more dramatic style 

Cons:

• This only comes in one shade of brown 

Neutrogena Healthy Lengths Mascara

Grow with glamour

Not just for looks, this version from Neutrogena doubles as a health-boosting, lash-lengthening formula as well.

Best Lengthening

Find on Amazon

There’s no need to double up on beauty products. This beautiful brown mascara defines your lashes each day while helping them become longer as well. It’s made with olive oil, vitamin E, and rice protein, all of which support the growth of healthy long lashes.

Along with keeping your lashes in an ideal shape, this mascara is designed to make them look great, too. The brown shade compliments many eye colors and skin tones, while the soft-bristled brush allows for a naturally soft look. Just the act of successfully separating each lash will provide a look that’s easy to love.

Pros:

• This product is tested by dermatologists and ophthalmologists for complete safety
• It’s designed to be clump, smudge, and flake-proof

Cons:

• This doesn’t provide a dramatic look, but multiple coats can be used for a longer and darker appearance

Maybelline Sky High Waterproof Mascara

Worry-free water days

Try this fully waterproof mascara to keep your style intact through any type of play.

Best Waterproof

Find on Amazon

No one wants their mascara running when they spend time in the water. Luckily, this product from Maybelline is designed to last through pools, beach days, and more, so you can keep your style in perfect condition all day long.

This brown mascara provides a dramatic look with its volumizing formula and its wand that’s perfect for separating and curling lashes of any length. Its brownish-black color is noticeable without being completely black, so you can match your perfect color palette while still creating a style that stands out.

Pros:

• This formula works well for people with and without sensitive skin
• It has bamboo extract and fibers for added lengthening power
• Washable versions are available if you don’t need the waterproof feature 

Cons:

•  Since this is waterproof, you’ll need a makeup-removing product to take it off

Ecco Bella FlowerColor Mascara

Vegan vogue

Living a plant-based lifestyle? Let the trend continue with this incredibly beautiful, plant-based brown mascara.

Best Plant-Based

Find on Amazon

If you live a vegan lifestyle, you might as well make sure your mascara matches up to your mission. This plant-based formula is made of carnauba wax, palm oil, and clay, giving you a noteworthy style without the added chemicals or non-vegan ingredients.

Along with being made well, this brown mascara provides an excellent look. Its smooth formula won’t clump or cake, and its all-around wand coats every lash for a fuller, longer look after application. The tube even has a mirror on its surface for convenient on-the-go use.

Pros:

• This mascara is long-lasting and water-resistant
• It’s easy to remove without scrubbing, so your eyes can be treated as delicately as possible
• It’s cruelty-free and harsh chemical-free as well as plant-based

Cons:

• With its unique ingredient list, this brown mascara is more expensive than most

Frequently Asked Questions

Which brown mascara creates the most dramatic look?

All products that list dark, voluminous, lengthening, or defining characteristics will provide a noticeable lift to your lashes. You can always use multiple coats to create a look that stands out as well.

What other makeup products work well with brown mascara?

Brown mascara typically provides a more natural look than the commonly-used black versions. Because of this, it works well with soft daytime makeups such as earth tone eyeshadows, brown eyeliner, and your typical foundation routine.