The Best Stove Burner Covers

The Best Stove Burner Covers

Cleaning your stovetop can be quite the task, and the longer you go between cleanings, the harder it is to scour off the splatters and drips. A sparkling clean stove can transform your kitchen, but sometimes it doesn't seem worth the hassle. For a convenient way to cover up less-than-pretty stovetops and protect your burners from messes, stove burner covers are the way to go. Read on for our top picks for stove burner covers that will keep your stoves cleaner and your kitchen looking more organized.

Reston Lloyd Electric Stove Burner Covers

A cover for all

These round stove top covers come in a variety of colors and patterns that will look right at home in any kitchen.
Best Overall

Find on Amazon

You might say that Reston Lloyd’s burner covers are crowdpleasers. Not only does the set comes in two sizes to accommodate different stovetops, but it’s also available in a myriad of colors and patterns, from standard to kitschy. The tin covers are sturdy, but you need to be careful with placing anything too heavyweight on them. A word of caution: be sure you know what burner you’re turning on, otherwise you may burn one of the covers by accident. We recommend taking all the covers off when cooking, just to be safe, but these are so lightweight to handle that it’s not a problem.

Pros:

  • Comes in two sizes that will fit in most burners
  • Ideal for a decorative touch in the kitchen
  • Adds protection to your stovetop from pets who tend to jump onto surfaces

Cons:

  • Not heat-resistant, so you need to be careful if you cover your burners while they’re still warm

Stock Your Home Stove Burner Covers

Easy and breezy

These disposable covers are a serious timesaver.
Best Disposable

Find on Amazon

If there’s a way to save us headaches cleaning in the kitchen, we tend to take advantage of it, and these disposable burner covers definitely fit the bill. These are designed for electric stoves, so they’ll fit conveniently into most electric stovetops’ drip pans to catch oil splatters and other spills. All you have to do is throw them away when it’s time. For those who have been using aluminum foil to cover their burners, consider these a much-needed upgrade that will save you time and headaches.

Pros:

  • Comes in a value pack containing six- and eight-inch covers (25 each in a pack)
  • Can easily double up on pans for extra strength and just remove the top layer when it’s dirty
  • Easy to switch out

Cons:

  • These are meant to be disposable, so they might feel too flimsy if you are looking for something more durable

Vaxaape Stove Burner Covers

The right amount of flex

If you want a long-lasting, reusable stove top cover, this one will stick around for a long time.
Easiest To Clean

Find on Amazon

Part of the point of burner covers is to save on cleanup time, so it might seem odd to buy reusable covers. But the beauty here is that you can reuse these covers and reduce waste while keeping the burner underneath as good as new. These covers are made of PTFE Teflon-coated material, meaning they’re nonstick and can withstand temperatures up to 500 °F. That does not mean these are fireproof though, so make sure the covers are not coming in direct contact with the burner’s flame. While they’re flexible, they still feel sturdy. Not only that, but their lightweight construction and black color mean they blend in well with most stovetops.

Pros:

  • Can cut them to accommodate your stove
  • Dishwasher-safe, though we do recommend handwashing
  • Cut down on waste

Cons:

  • Not for electric stoves

Miles Kimball Marble Burner Covers

More than meets the eye

This chic cover is perfect for a variety of stove sizes.
Most Versatile Size

Find on Amazon

You may not think that something as practical as a stovetop cover could be described as “chic,” but Miles Kimball’s covers are enough to convince us otherwise. Constructed from enameled metal, the marbled design adds a subtle but stylish feel to your kitchen, and they come in neutral covers that match most kitchens. The large size is particularly ideal for adding more surface space to your kitchen while looking sleek. If you’re the type who’s always cooking or meal prepping and constantly looking around for more space, these covers come in handy.

Pros:

  • Large rectangular sizes are versatile for many stovetops, whether your burners are round or rectangular
  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Stylish look

Cons:

  • Rimmed edges may not cover your burners entirely

Kitchen Basics 101 Porcelain Drip Pans

A perfect fit

These sturdy, convenient covers are designed to blend seamlessly with your stovetop.
Best Reusable

Find on Amazon

These porcelain drip pans feel like the best of both worlds: they’re sleek and blend in well with most stovetops, but reuse them, so you don’t have to keep buying new ones. We like the idea of treating these as if they were the original drip pans that came with your stove. They certainly look like they could be, and they hold up well after multiple washes while your stove’s real drip pans will be safe from grime and grit. These drip pans can serve as a replacement and instantly give your stovetop a new look and feel as well.

Pros:

  • Constructed of durable porcelain
  • Black color hides any splatters well if you don’t feel like cleaning it right away
  • Dishwasher-safe, though we recommend handwashing

Cons:

  • These aren’t as easy to wash as a Teflon-coated product would be after food or spills have been sitting too long

Frequently Asked Questions

Why should I handwash the stove burner covers?

Even if they’re dishwasher-safe, we typically recommend handwashing metal or Teflon-coated products in order to prevent rust or wearing out the nonstick coating, respectively. We find that handwashing usually helps products last longer as well. Make sure to properly dry the covers to keep them in tip-top shape.

How should I clean drip pans? 

For tougher stains or cooked-on food, we recommend soaking drip pans in baking soda and vinegar for about ten minutes. You can also soak the pans for ten minutes in hot water beforehand to soften anything crusted on it.