The Best Muffin Pans for Your Home

Caketime 12-Cup Silicone Muffin Pan

Muffin to write home about

This silicone muffin pan by Caketime delivers superb results for a fraction of the cost of typical bakeware.

Best Overall

Find on Amazon

This cheerful, brightly-colored muffin pan cooks (and cleans up) like a dream. Made of food-grade silicone that is guaranteed to be BPA-free, you can microwave, freeze or bake any food you have in mind, and then toss the pan in the dishwasher for easy clean-up when you’re done. Although these work for virtually any muffin recipe, this really is an amazing product for those who like to food-prep egg muffin creations. Never again will you have burnt pieces of egg stuck to the sides of your muffin pans — whatever you cook in this silicone muffin pan will just pop right out.

Pros:

• Truly a low-maintenance product
• Great value for the price
• No need to use liners or grease the pan prior to use

Cons:

• Some may not be fans of the flashy red coloring

Amazon Basics Nonstick Muffin Pan (Set of 2)

Cheaper by the dozen

Why get one lovely muffin tin when you can get two instead?

Best Set

Find on Amazon

If you’re in search of a pair of well-rounded baking pans, this is it. Affordable and well-made, these do the job they’re meant to without putting a dent in your bank account. With twelve cups in each pan, you can bake enough muffins to feed your kid’s entire class, and thanks to the nonstick coating, you shouldn’t have to scrub those stubborn bits of burnt-on muffin after you’re done.

Pros:

• You can buy silicone baking cups to fit into the tray for minimal cleanup
• Large enough to feed an entire class of kids
• Distribute heat evenly

Cons:

• Shouldn’t be put in the dishwasher

Wilton Jumbo Muffin Pan

A jumbo tin for the win

This one's a high-quality muffin pan for all of those jumbo-muffin lovers out there.

Best Jumbo Size

Find on Amazon

For all of you jumbo muffin lovers out there: this muffin pan by Wilton is a score. Not only do you get a set of two, but this non-stick muffin pan also delivers delicious, moist, and puffy muffins without sticking, while the quality construction ensures that heat will spread evenly without warping. A company that has been around for almost a century, Wilton has stood the test of time. Regardless of your baking skills, this muffin pan consistently helps to create a fun and easy solution to what can often be a messy kitchen adventure.

Pros:

• Nonstick, easy-to-clean muffin pan; No more burnt-on edges
• Edges are wide, making gripping a hot pan easy

Cons:

• These muffin pans work better with muffin liners

Wilton Perfect Results Mini Muffin Pan

Small is beautiful

For the at-home baker who likes to create pro-quality baked goods, this mini-muffin pan by Wilton is top-of-the-line.

Best For Mini Muffins

Find on Amazon

While the classic muffin obviously has its time and place, for some of us, nothing trumps the mini-muffin. If you find yourself in this boat, then you’ll want to scoop Wilton’s mini-muffin pan, because not only is it cute, but more importantly, it’ll help you make the best darn mini muffins around. Being that they’re so small, mini muffins are more delicate than their regular-sized counterparts, and thanks to this pan’s reinforced nonstick coating, these won’t get stuck to the pan and fall apart when you try to slide them out.

Pros:

• Also great for making mini cupcakes
• Heavy-duty construction will last the test of time

Cons:

• A tad bit difficult to clean

Wilton Premium Nonstick Covered Muffin Pan

Got you covered

Unlike most baking pans on the market, this one comes with a helpful cover included.

Best With Cover

Find on Amazon

If you don’t already know why you’d need a muffin pan that comes with a cover, let us elucidate. While traditional muffins don’t need to be cooked in a pan with a cover, other types of muffins can really benefit from it. If you plan on using egg as a base for your muffin, or you’d like to experiment with alternative flours like those made of coconut or almond, you’ll likely want a cover. Because these flours bake a bit differently, the cover helps distribute the heat differently. This can help ensure the finished product comes out exactly the way you intended it.

Pros:

• Great for those on low-carb diets
• Good value considering the pan’s quality and the included cover

Cons:

• Not as nonstick as one might hope for

Frequently Asked Questions

What should you look for in a quality muffin pan?

Although it depends on what you’re typically cooking in a muffin pan, if you’d like a versatile option that delivers professional results, you’ll want to look for either an extremely high-quality silicone muffin pan, or a tin muffin pan that is light in color. As a general rule, the darker the color of the metal of the muffin pan, the more that your cooked product will brown. If you do go the metal route, you’ll want a thick and very durable metal that won’t warp, and also one that facilitates even cooking.

How can a muffin pan affect your baking?

For those of you who are wondering if a muffin pan can actually affect the results of your muffins, the answer is yes, absolutely. If you go for a budget muffin pan that really is low-quality, you’ll likely have sub-par results. Although price does not always equal quality, it’s best to check out the reviews for a product such as a muffin pan. You don’t want a batter that sticks to the edges and causes baked goods to burn, stick, or dry out.