The Best Colanders for Your Kitchen

The Best Colanders for Your Kitchen

Colanders are an essential kitchen tool perfect for daily tasks like straining pasta, rinsing canned food, and washing produce. Straining hot foods can be dangerous, but using a sturdy, well-made colander makes the process easy and safe — no more splashing hot water around the kitchen or onto yourself. They come in a wide variety of shapes, sizes, and materials, including metal and silicone, and each style has its own unique benefits. Whether you are a pro making pasta alla Genovese or a beginner trying your hand at spaghetti and meatballs, we’ve researched the best colanders available to help you make the best choice for your cooking needs.

Longzon Collapsible Silicone Strainer Set

Saving space

For excellent durability combined with an easy-to-store design, look no further than these collapsible colanders.
Best Overall

Find on Amazon

When you have a small kitchen, owning efficient tools that maximize space is essential. These two colanders are made of durable silicone, and they collapse flat for effortless storage in a cupboard or drawer. That means they’re also great for RVs and camping when packing light is paramount. The large handles and heat-resistant silicone also make blanching vegetables simple since the colanders can be immersed in boiling and cold water while retaining their shape and structural integrity.

Pros:

  • Heat-resistant up to 230˚F
  • BPA-free silicone
  • Easy to clean

Cons:

  • Only has drainage holes on the bottom
  • While the flexible silicone allows for easy storage, it is less sturdy than metal

ExcelSteel Colander Set

Triple threat

With three nesting colanders, this stainless steel set is well-equipped to handle any size portion.
Best Stainless Steel

Find on Amazon

They say three’s a crowd, but in this case, it’s perfect company. This set of colanders includes a 1-quart, 2.5-quart, and 4-quart version, and each is finished with oversize handles for easy lifting. They’re constructed out of stainless steel, which is durable, easy to clean, and won’t retain odors. Each colander also has a sturdy base, so you can place it in the sink and pour hot items without worrying about holding it steady. With this set, you can be like Goldilocks and always have the colander that’s just right for whatever size portion you’re preparing.

Pros:

  • Stable base makes it easy to set on a counter or in the sink
  • Stainless steel is light and durable
  • Each colander nests for easy storage

Cons:

  • Metal handles can get hot
  • Has fewer holes than other colanders, which keeps small foods in but can slow down drainage

Popco Wide Collapsible Colanders (Set of 3)

Shape shifters

These sturdy, no-frills colanders are reliable and sophisticated, and best of all, they collapse down when they're not in use.
Best Collapsible

Find on Amazon

Pressed for space? Whether you’re living the van life or simply trying to make the most out of a cramped kitchen, these collapsible colanders are worth considering. Made from food-grade, BPA-free rubber and silicone, these colanders collapse down to just over an inch in height, making them extremely easy to store away when you don’t need to use them. They’re heat-resistant, dishwasher-safe, and very easy to clean by hand thanks to their silicone construction. Simply put, they’re a delight to use and they’re offered at a great price point.

Pros:

  • Available in round or square configurations
  • Quite affordable considering there are three per set
  • Very easy to clean

Cons:

  • Though it’s nice to have three colanders, it would make more sense if each was differently sized

Qimh Collapsible Over-the-Sink Colander

The home stretch

Featuring two extendable handles, this roomy colander stretches to conveniently fit over your sink for stability while pouring.
Best Over-The-Sink Model

Find on Amazon

For hands-free functionality, it’s tough to beat this collapsible colander. The extendable handles reach across the sink, suspending the colander so you can easily rinse food without having to hold it steady. Additionally, the hard plastic and silicone are both long-lasting and dishwasher-safe, which makes cleanup simple. Finally, the roomy, six-quart capacity basin is perfect if you’re cooking for a crowd.

Pros:

  • Environmentally friendly materials
  • Anti-skid base prevents slipping
  • Compresses flat for easy storage

Cons:

  • Square sides can make it harder to pour out food
  • May be unnecessarily big for smaller portions

Prepworks by Progressive Can Colander

Make straining a snap

For straining the contents of cans safely and more easily than ever before, this clip-on colander is second to none.
Best For Cans

Find on Amazon

This tiny snap-on colander might look a bit unusual, but what it lacks in size, it makes up for in utility. The clever design allows you to drain off liquid directly from cans. If you’ve ever tried to open the lid of a can just enough to drain the liquid without letting the contents fall out, you’ll know it’s easier said than done. This strainer does away with the need to do that, making the process of draining cans more convenient and safer for your fingers.

Pros:

  • Small and easy to store
  • BPA-free material
  • Snaps onto standard-sized cans easily

Cons:

  • Not ideal for tuna cans

Frequently Asked Questions

Which is better, silicone or stainless steel?

Silicone and stainless steel are both heat-resistant and durable, which is important when handling hot foods. Silicone is flexible, which means that it’s excellent for collapsible colanders when storage space is a concern. It also doesn’t conduct heat, so you can’t accidentally burn yourself by touching silicone handles. Stainless steel is solid, and the handles are usually riveted on, so these colanders will be sturdier than silicone. As with most kitchen tools, the best choice for you depends on your preferences and needs.

What type of drainage holes should I look for?

That depends on how you plan to use your colander. If you’ll be rinsing a lot of rice, small grains, or thin pasta, look for a colander with many small holes. If you’ll be straining larger kinds of pasta or rinsing vegetables, large holes or slots allow the liquid to drain out as quickly as possible.