The Best Cookie Variety Packs

Nabisco Cookies & Crackers Variety Pack

Nothin' but the Hits

No surprises here — these treats have stood the test of time for a reason.

Best Overall

Find on Amazon

If we had to pick one tried-and-true, complete crowd-pleaser of an assortment, this would undoubtedly be it. This pack is chock-full of timeless classic snacks, from Oreos and Teddy Grahams for those with a sweet tooth to Ritz Bits and Wheat Thins for those who prefer a savory treat. And featuring a whopping 48 single-serving packages, this is by far the most substantial array of goodies we found. With so many options, this is a fantastic choice for tons of scenarios — you could feed a team of kids a post-game snack, have bags ready for playdates or sleepovers, or store some at the office in your desk.

Pros:

• All these snacks are familiar to kids, which means this will satisfy even the pickiest of eaters
• Packs are small enough so the contents won’t spoil appetites, yet substantial enough to hold kids over
• Fantastic value

Cons:

• Some items may become broken during shipping

Fat Snax Mini Keto Cookies Variety Pack

Mini-Me

Ditch the carbs and keep the cookie with these keto-friendly crowdpleasers.

Best Keto Option

Find on Amazon

These cookies by Fat Snax are simply a mini-version of their already insanely popular full-sized ones, and they’re every bit as delicious. You’ll get three of the brand’s most popular flavors in this assortment — Chocolate Chip, Snickerdoodle, and Double Chocolate — all of which have under 2 net carbs and absolutely zero sugar. We also love that these tiny treats are crunchier than their larger counterparts, as it makes them perfect for milk-dunking. But our favorite thing is that each pack is actually resealable, so if you have the willpower to only eat a few at a time (in which case, we salute you), you know the rest will stay fresh.

Pros:

• Company is known for excellent customer service
• A great option to keep in your car or bag if you need a quick cookie-fix

Cons:

• The texture may be too grainy for some people’s preference

Lenny & Larry’s Complete Cookie Variety Pack

The Bigger, the Better

These jumbo-sized cookies are the perfect option when you really want to treat yourself.

Biggest Cookies

Find on Amazon

Sometimes we wonder — why on earth would anyone eat a small dessert when they could have a huge one? Moderation is definitely not the key with these gigantic treats, but everyone deserves a little something extra now and then. And a great thing about L&L’s massive cookies is that they’re actually — gasp — kind of healthy. Each of the eight flavors, including snickerdoodle, chocolate chip, and oatmeal raisin, is entirely plant-based, vegan, and non-GMO. Along with providing 10g of fiber, these sweet treats are also made using minimally processed ingredients and only real cane sugar.

Pros:

• Easy to bring on the go since each cookie is individually wrapped
• Super filling and can be a suitable replacement for a meal if you’re in a time crunch

Cons:

• Some ingredients may cause bloating for those with a sensitive stomach

The Cravory’s Variety Pack

(Almost) Too Pretty to Eat

These cookies combine grown-up flavors with a whimsical aesthetic.

Best For Your Inner Child

Find on Amazon

This assortment of cookies gives us serious nostalgia vibes. The bright colors, the sprinkles, the gooey-ness — we’re already drooling. In addition to the go-to favorites like sprinkles and chocolate chip, this box includes indulgent flavors like Cookie Monster (which has two additional kinds of cookies mixed in along with marshmallows) and luxurious Red Velvet. These cookies are wrapped individually and are great on their own, but we recommend zapping them in the microwave for a minute for an extra decadent treat.

Pros:

• The packaging is extremely secure to ensure no breakage or crumbling occurs during shipping
• This company was started by just two people, so your purchase will be supporting a small business

Cons:

• More expensive than some of the comparable assortment packs

Doughp Edible and Bakeable Cookie Dough

No Baking Necessary

This innovative treat has changed the cookie dough game forever.

Best Dough

Find on Amazon

There are two kinds of people in the world: those who eat cookie dough and those who are missing out on the greatest thing ever. Licking the beaters may be delicious, but it can pose serious health risks due to the raw eggs in the batter. However, those dangers are now gone thanks to this completely edible, eggless cookie dough. Each of these four delicious flavors has a mere six ingredients, and the flour is even heat-treated to ensure that any traces of potentially hazardous bacteria are eliminated. So go ahead and grab a spoon — we won’t judge, as long as you save some for us.

Pros:

• Can be eaten raw or baked like traditional cookie dough
• Dough will stay fresh for up to six weeks in the fridge and a year in the freezer

Cons:

• The packaging is a bit fragile and may dent during the shipping process

Frequently Asked Questions

Some of these packs have so many items — will they spoil?

As always, consult the nutrition info to be sure you’re snacking safely. Many variety packs contain individually-wrapped items to make sure your purchase lasts as long as you need it to. In many cases, that can be about a year. Those that are shipped directly from a bakery are another story, as they’ll have to be enjoyed before too much time has passed if you want the quality to remain high. But we wouldn’t worry too much about that — they’re so tasty, we think they’ll be gone before you know it.