The Best Pizza Peels

New Star Foodservice Wooden Pizza Peel

Quality matters

Here you'll find a solid wooden pizza peel that's easy to maneuver.

Best Overall

Find on Amazon

New Star Foodservice is well known in the service industry for selling high-quality products at reasonable prices, and this pizza peel is case in point. Featuring a tapered blade, this peel ensures your pizza will slide smoothly on and off the peel’s surface. The handle is easy to hold and sturdy enough to support the weight of even the heaviest of pizza pies. You can even get one with a longer handle for a deeper oven. Caring for this peel is super simple, so it should be easy to keep it in tip-top condition for years to come.

Pros:

• Easy to care for with some basic mineral oil
• Comes in a wide variety of sizes, so you’re sure to find one that’ll fit your needs
• Smooth finish allows a clean transfer of your pizza
• Versatile enough to use for pizza, cakes, pies, and more

Cons:

• Without the mineral oil, it may become dried out, so remember to care for it
• Hand-wash only

Checkered Chef Extra-Large Pizza Peel

That's amore

If you plan on making big pizza pies, you'll want a large pizza peel like this one to accommodate them.

Best Extra Large

Find on Amazon

Equipped with a thin, stainless steel paddle, this pizza peel from Checkered Chef is ideal for anyone looking to make pizza pies on the larger side. Aside from being strong enough to support the weight of heavy pies, this one also boasts a folding handle, so it’s easy to store when you’re done with it. Any self-proclaimed pizzaiolo needs a reliable peel like this one to get the job done right.

Pros:

• Has a rubber handle, so no need to worry about splinters
• Can also be used for pies and cakes
• Made of durable stainless steel

Cons:

• It’s a bit heavy, so those with conditions like arthritis might need something less cumbersome

Chef Pomodoro Aluminum Pizza Peel with Foldable Handle

Compact and lightweight

With this one, you get a lightweight aluminum pizza peel with a folding handle for the ultimate convenience.

Easiest To Store

Find on Amazon

Are you looking for a quality pizza peel that you can use in a kitchen where you’re pressed for space? If so, Chef Pomodoro’s pizza peel may be just what you are looking for. It sports a durable aluminum surface that allows the pizza to very easily slide on and off of it. The handle is made of wood and can be folded down over the peel itself. Once fully folded, it can fit in nearly any cabinet space so that it’s out of your way when you don’t need it. Meanwhile, when it is open, it’s large enough to make transferring any pizza quick and easy.

Pros:

• Easy to care for with a simple hand-wash
• Folds up compactly
• It is versatile and easy to use
• The handle locks in and is very strong when open

Cons:

• You do need to periodically check to ensure that the bolt and knob are tight enough

New Star Foodservice Aluminum Pizza Peel

I've got it handled

Thanks to its extra-long handle, this pizza peel ensures you'll never get burned when sliding your pizza into the oven.

Best Long Handle

Find on Amazon

When we think about pizza peels, it isn’t just the paddle that makes them what they are; it’s the long handle, too. Designed to protect you from burning yourself on the edge of a hot oven, the long handle on this peel lets you handle your pizza pie without having to come near that infernal heat. Anyone who’s been overzealous to get that yummy pizza out of the oven would be wise to pick up a peel with a long handle like this one.

Pros:

• Made of natural basswood and anodized aluminum
• Available in different sizes so that you can choose the perfect one for your kitchen
• Blade and handle are tightly secured

Cons:

• Can be tricky learning to use it properly

Heritage Acacia Wood Pizza Peel

Find your purpose

Whether you're baking bread, cooking pizza, or perfecting that apple pie recipe, this peel will help you do it all.

Best Multipurpose

Find on Amazon

While it’s truly a blast making your own pizza at home, how often do you really do it? If you’re someone who only makes a pizza once in a blue moon, it might be hard to justify buying your own pizza peel. But with this one from Heritage, you’ll get enough use out of it even if you’re only a casual pizzaiolo. That’s because it can be used for just about anything that involves the oven. Whether you’re baking cakes, pies, or bread, this marvelous wooden peel is there to ensure that the job gets done right.

Pros:

• Dimensions are excellently balanced; strong without being too thick and large without being cumbersome
• Has a hole through the handle so you can hang it on the wall
• High-quality acacia wood

Cons:

• Wood may crack over time

Frequently Asked Questions

Do I need a pizza peel to make pizza?

You do not need a pizza peel to make pizza, however, it makes it exponentially easier. A peel makes it so you can build and transfer the pizza all on one surface to avoid losing toppings or splitting the dough.

Should I get a wooden or metal pizza peel?

Wooden pizza peels are usually more durable and can hold heavier pizzas. Meanwhile, aluminum is easier to maneuver and easier to care for. Determine which style better suits your needs and go from there.