The Best Two-Slice Toasters

Cuisinart Two-Slice Compact Plastic Toaster

Tried and true

You can't go wrong with this classic toaster.

Best Overall

Find on Amazon

When it comes to kitchen appliances, Cuisinart is one of the most trusted names in the game, known for devices that are well-made and reliable. The same is true for this excellent two-slice toaster. It features settings for toasting, reheating, defrosting, and even preparing bagels. The defrost setting is great for those who like to freeze their bread since you can defrost your slices first before toasting with just one appliance. The bagel setting heats only the cut side of the bagel to create a crunchy top and a chewy bottom. Each toasting slot is 1.5″ wide, and there’s a slide-out crumb tray for easy cleaning.

Pros:

• Easy-to-read shade dial so you can get your desired toast level (light, medium, or dark)
• Cord wrap contains cord under the toaster for a neat appearance and streamlined storage

Cons:

• Plastic material of the toaster makes it affordable but less professional looking than a metal toaster

Cuisinart Metal Classic Two-Slice Toaster

Shine and class

This stainless steel toaster would look lovely on any countertop.

Best Classic Design

Find on Amazon

This beauty by Cuisinart has a timeless stainless steel design that features polished chrome and black accents that look just as luxurious as they feel. The bottom of the toaster is securely cased, so you won’t have to worry about any wobbling. The toasting slots are BPA-free and boast a six-shade dial. Settings 1 – 2 will result in a light toast, 3 – 4 are for medium, and 5 – 6 will make your toast dark and crunchy. Once the toast is finished, you can use the high lift lever that allows the toast carriage to pop up extra high. You’ll be able to get your toast out with ease, without ever burning your hands.

Pros:

• Thick slots can accommodate French toast, frozen pancakes, and toaster pastries
• Reheat setting allows you to reheat bread without burning it

Cons:

• Weighs a bit over four pounds, making it heavier than some other toasters

Black + Decker Two-Slice Extra Wide Slot Toaster

Fit a square into an oval

This modern toaster can fit an array of toasted treats.

Best With Extra Wide Slots

Find on Amazon

The rounded shape of this toaster oven makes it quite unique. It features a black plastic exterior with sleek metallic silver accents. Best of all, this toaster has extra-wide and deep toasting slots that can accommodate thick slices of toast and bagels. In terms of toasting power, it has seven settings so that you can nail the exact texture you want. The self-adjusting guides in the toasting slots will securely hold your bread for even toasting.

Pros:

• Extra lifted toast lever puts the finished product safely within reach
• Keeps your counters clean with a drop-down crumb tray
• Very affordable for the quality

Cons:

• Wider design means this toaster will take up a little more room in your kitchen than other options

Dash Clear View Toaster

Clearly clever

This toaster features an ingenious glass window so that you can monitor your toast's progress.

Most Innovative

Find on Amazon

Never burn your toast again with this gorgeous appliance by Dash. It comes in several chic colors and features a large glass window that lets you see your toast browning so that you can get the perfect color every time. It takes all the guesswork out of getting the perfect toast. Unlike a traditional toaster with two slots, Dash’s toaster has one long slot that allows you to fit a longer baguette slice or bigger frozen pancake without having to cut it. This toaster also has an automatic shutoff feature to prevent overheating.

Pros:

• 42-inch cord reaches far with ease
• Crumb tray and glass window slide out easily for cleaning
• Has defrost, reheat, and bagel settings

Cons:

• Takes up more countertop room lengthwise than an average toaster

Hello Kitty Two-Slice Wide-Slot Toaster

For toast that smiles back

Start your morning with the cutest toast you've ever seen.

Most Unique

Find on Amazon

How adorable is this Hello Kitty toaster? It’s a collector’s item for sure. The cartoon design and pink accents will bring joy and personality to any kitchen. You may think it looks too much like a toy to be functional, but you’d be surprised — it has extra-wide slots, seven levels of browning, and a high-lift carriage for easy toast removal. Best of all, it imprints a Hello Kitty face onto every piece of toast. If your kids are reluctant to eat breakfast, this will surely make it a more fun experience for them. Regardless of your age, this toaster will remind you to enjoy the little things in life.

Pros:

• Seven dial settings
• Cool-touch exterior

Cons:

• You may have to toast extra dark for the Hello Kitty imprint to show up

Frequently Asked Questions

What are some important things to look for in a toaster? 
When it comes to a toaster, make sure you’re looking at the size of the toasting slots, the toaster’s overall size, and the number of settings. If you’re a fan of thick toast, French toast, or frozen waffles, it’s best to go with slots that are 1.5″ or wider. Generally, it’s nice to have a toaster that takes up less counter space but still has roomy toasting slots. Another thing to look at is the number of shade settings. That way, you can figure out the precise brownness level for your perfect toast.

How can I clean my toaster?
In most cases, toasters don’t need regular cleaning. They should stay dry and relatively clean as long as you remember to empty the crumb tray. For a deeper clean, you can clean the crumb tray with warm water and soap. You can also wipe the outside of the toaster with a gentle wipe or cloth. The knobs can tend to build up with oil, so make sure to wipe those too. With just a little maintenance, your toaster should hold up well over time.